Why I write Book Reviews

I love reading. Probably books and the written word were my first true love, imagining existence in the spaces they created is a close second.  And I’ve read just about every genre and style out there.  I’ve read the classics: I have a crush on Shakespeare, wanted to meet A.A. Milne, have dinner with Flaubert, and danced over the island with Lucy Maud Montgomery.  A seat at the table at the Algonquin, and to know Rand well enough to know to duck from her acidity.

Now I can add many books to my collection without the worry of storage: my kindle and IPad give me the look of a fat kid in a bakery, too many choices all looking delicious. With so many choices and new discoveries, and friends looking for recommendations: I started writing reviews when I purchase a book, or when I add one to my goodreads page. Wait – you haven’t heard about goodreads? It’s a great site where readers can share, review, discuss and even find books, authors and genres that may interest them.  Feel free to “friend” me over there – I’m always looking to peek at bedside tables to see what is being read.

As I slowly compile my list there, I realized that many of the reviews that I have read are often missing pieces that I want to know about.  I don’t care so much about knowing that there are four characters, but if the four are flat and not developed, I need to know that.  I don’t want to see you hated a book without seeing the why. And, while I realize that everyone has a different experience with each book, there are some factors in every book that are not subjective: typos, editing, inappropriate or misused words.  Those all take away from the experience of reading; whether or not you like a book, and show me a lack of interest in the reader.  Writing a book is not easy, everyone may have one book they could write, not everyone will. And even the most seasoned writer will be so bold as to tell you that the process was “easy”.

Writing a review is, second only to purchase, possibly the best way I can say “thank you” to the author for the effort and energy expended.  Being sure to incorporate specificity and not just saying “I loved this book” shows that you truly thought about the story, the construction and the writer: you have balanced the positive and negative, you can show what was good and bad.  You aren’t looking to dash anyone’s hopes of being the next Stephen King with a snarky review, but you can point out where edits and spell check would be helpful.

Of course, I have come across stories that I thought were juvenile and in need of an editor and others that were just so perfectly enjoyable that finding something that didn’t work just never hit my radar. And I’m not so precious as to think that my reviews are the best, or should be your only input in choosing a new read: people appreciate different things in each book they encounter.

I’ve been incredibly fortunate to hear back from authors when I have reviewed their book. One told me that they appreciated the honest reviews that contained a mix of good and bad points, with a reason why something did or did not work.  They knew that the story was important enough TO the reader; they reflected on the story and were able to detail their likes and dislikes.  “There is much I can learn from an honest and thoughtful review” has been the statement from all authors who have responded to my reviews.

I don’t just read a book to review it: I want to revel in the story, escape, learn, be intrigued and care about the characters.  When it happens, it’s a magical moment. Coming to the last page of a good book is similar to saying goodbye to a friend; you want to know when you can meet again for coffee. Writing a review lets me extend that moment a bit longer, while being sure to thank the one who brought us together.

I selected this post to be featured on my blog’s page at Book Review Blogs.

4 thoughts on “Why I write Book Reviews

  1. Nicely put, for me readin is to be transported, I want to be there as part of the landscape observing first hand, I’ve not yet bought a kindle preferring the feel of the page, though I’m rapidly running out of space.

    You can add the Goodreads widget to your page.

  2. I think it’s wonderful that you write reviews, and that you put so much effort into them. I’ve read a fair few of yours, on Goodreads and Amazon, and I love that you go into details about what worked for you and what didn’t. I think that to trust a review you have to know the reviewer somewhat; not necessarily as a friend or acquaintance, but there needs to be something of them in what they write, some sense of personality and taste, some hint of whether you have enough in common with them to be able to utilise their opinion. You have that wonderful ability to give your own thoughts and feelings on something rather than parroting the blurb or a review you saw in a magazine or paper, the way so many do; to present your opinions and recognise them as such rather than presenting them as inalienable facts, and that is such a wonderful strength to have.

    I’d like to start reviewing things again, but as with everything – and particularly things that require mental energy like reviews and blogging – it is taking what seems like forever to get my wind back. In addition to which there is my unfortunate tendency to treat every piece of writing, even a comment on a thread or a blog post, as though it is an essay to be graded to the harshest standards. 🙂 Which, too often, leads to me putting it off – “until I can think about it and give a proper reply” – and often not doing it at all.

    So in short, HUGE kudos to you, both for writing the reviews in the first place, and for the thought you put into them.

    (I am not rereading this comment, or I will spend forever agonising over whether or not I said exactly what I wanted to say…I shall merely post, and hope that I can do the same in the future. It is such a trial, when words once obeyed you and fell into the right places with just a breath, and then suddenly they don’t!)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s